Impactful creator runs

[Perry]

Frank Miller

For me its Watchmen with League of Extraordinary Gentlemen a close second.

 

[Perry]

- Ed Brubaker - Captain America, Captain America, Captain America
- John Byrne - Alpha Flight, Fantastic Four, Superman (title relaunch), X-men
- Peter David - Captain Marvel, X-Factor, X-Factor
- Warren Ellis - Authority, Planetary, Planetary
- Garth Ennis - The Boys, Punisher Max, Punisher Max
- Jonathan Hickman - Fantastic Four, Fantastic Four, Fantastic Four
- Geoff Johns - Green Lantern, Green Lantern, Green Lantern
- Jeff Lemire - Mazebook, Tenement, **** 
- Frank Miller - Daredevil, Daredevil, Dark Knight Returns
- Alan Moore - Top 10, Watchmen, Whatever Happened...


Will the next one pose more of a challenge? For me? Yes? For you guys, no so sure. Next one up is...
Frank Miller



Grant Morrison

[Jeff]

Frank Miller

For me its Watchmen with League of Extraordinary Gentlemen a close second.

 

DANGIT!!!!!  I mean Alan Moore!      

[Jimmy T]

GRANT MORRISON!!!

What to DO

Animal Man
Doom Patrol
Batman & Damian's introduction!
(let alone Arkham Aslyum!)
Seven Soldiers of Victory
Final Crisis
JLA
Superman New 52
All-Star Superman
Multiversity
WE3!!!!
Joe the Barbarian
New X-men

What to pick, what to pick.....

[Perry]

I know what I am picking
Not even close

[Jimmy T]

I choose....

His Batman Run

Morrison's run really invigorated the Batman line again. I feel that all Batman since has dealt with his writing, as well as continue to use it for an influence.

You have Damian Wayne.
You have Zur En Ah
You have the 'death' of Bruce Wayne from Final Crisis to his Return of Batman story as he's lost through time (the 5 gates & families of Gotham)
Batman Incorporated
Batman & Robin

Such great artists all along the way too!

He's etched his name on the mountainside of greatest Batman writers.

[Perry]

Morrison is an odd writer for me, I either love his stuff or find it very off putting. I love his "crazy, out of the box thinking" style, most times, but there are times when he just 'Out Morrisons' himself, because he was either really tore up on drugs or so deep in his head that it spoils the story (IE any Crisis book he has touched... or his Invisibles). That said, he is still responsible for creating (co-creating) one of my favorite stories of all time. My pick, forever, is...

All-Star Superman

When you can get me to thoroughly fall in love with a Superman story, hell, Superman as a character, you've done something. Now this is (honestly) more of a group effort pick because I have to question if I would have chosen this if Frank Quietly was NOT the artist on the book? Probably not... well... maybe not, but he was and the story was great, so easily my pick

[Jimmy T]

I was afraid I would be too much of a homer if I picked All-Star!

But totally worthy of the pick!

And Final Crisis, and the 3 part Superman tie-in, were amazing!

[Perry]

And Final Crisis, and the 3 part Superman tie-in, were amazing!

Yeah... that is going to be yet another, in a long line of things, that we disagree on


Final Crisis is a crapfest

[Jeff]

Grant Morrison

For me it's gotta be Doom Patrol.  He redefined the team and brought us Crazy Jane. I love Crazy Jane.

[Jimmy T]

And Final Crisis, and the 3 part Superman tie-in, were amazing!

Yeah... that is going to be yet another, in a long line of things, that we disagree on


Final Crisis is a crapfest

boooo

a crapfest?

Bah
and
Feh

[Perry]

Next item up for bid... I mean next creator up for voting (and one that I will stress over days after making my choice, because I want to pick them all)...

George Perez

******************************************************

- Ed Brubaker - Captain America, Captain America, Captain America
- John Byrne - Alpha Flight, Fantastic Four, Superman (title relaunch), X-men
- Peter David - Captain Marvel, X-Factor, X-Factor
- Warren Ellis - Authority, Planetary, Planetary
- Garth Ennis - The Boys, Punisher Max, Punisher Max
- Jonathan Hickman - Fantastic Four, Fantastic Four, Fantastic Four
- Geoff Johns - Green Lantern, Green Lantern, Green Lantern
- Jeff Lemire - Mazebook, Tenement, **** 
- Frank Miller - Daredevil, Daredevil, Dark Knight Returns
- Alan Moore - Top 10, Watchmen, Whatever Happened...
- Grant Morrison - All-Star Superman, Batman, Doom Patrol

[Jimmy T]

This is almost impossible! He's such a landmark figure, an artist on a pedestal or worship all to himself!

[Jimmy T]

Like, I almost ONLY want to pick the covers of issues 6 & 7 for Crisis on Infinite Earths (Supergirl's death, Flash dead covers)

[Jeff]

George Perez

For me it's going to be the New Teen Titans.  There's only one cover that always comes to mind when I hear his name. New Teen Titans #13.  It was my first realization of how much detail he puts into backgrounds and when he was solidified as my favorite artist.